The Scoreboard Can’t Tell You Who You Are

For athletes, the game is only part of the story. Identity Sports is helping players look beyond wins, losses, and statistics to find purpose, build faith, and discover who they are off the field. Photo courtesy of Pexels.

Insider Info

A famous last name, an Instagram Reel, and a golf ball with a cross on it? Yep, there's a story here! John Daly II, son of golf legend John Daly, shared with Identity Sports how discovering “Nobody” by Casting Crowns while scrolling Instagram inspired him to start marking his golf balls with a cross. Who knew a little social media scrolling could lead to something so meaningful?

The idea is simple: What happens when the sport that has defined you no longer does?

A 2026 Harvard report found that 51% of adults ages 18 to 29 reported lacking meaning or purpose, or both. Yet 79% of respondents wanted future jobs focused on helping others or making a positive difference. Identity Sports is building athlete-led Bible-study groups around that search for purpose. The nonprofit teaches that athletes’ worth comes from their Christian faith rather than their stats, playing time, or achievements.

“When baseball was taken away, it felt like my identity was taken away with it,” says Zach Vogel, executive director of Identity Sports. “I had built everything around what I did and who I thought I was going to become. When that disappeared, I didn’t know who I was anymore.”

From Player To Mentor

Vogel was 10 when a medical condition ended his ability to play sports. The experience eventually shaped his faith and his work with Identity Sports. Now, rather than stopping at a book or podcast, he wants athletes to have people they can turn to week after week.

The organization’s inaugural 12 Identity Captains, a mix of athletes, coaches, and leaders, are helping make that happen by leading discussions and mentoring future leaders.

Groups operate in Arizona, Michigan, Mississippi, Texas, Florida, and Montana, with virtual studies reaching additional states.

The gatherings look different from team to team, but they share a purpose: giving athletes room to discuss pressure, setbacks, self-doubt, and faith with people who understand the demands of competition.

A Different Kind Of Team Huddle

These aren’t your typical team meetings. Instead of breaking down plays, athletes are talking about the stuff that doesn’t always come up in the locker room.

The 12-week Identity Groups follow four themes: Foundation, Pressure, Adversity, and Purpose. Instead of judging a performance, the goal is to build relationships that last beyond a season.

Former Duke quarterback and ICF-credentialed coach Chris Katrenick leads one virtual Bible study for high school athletes, discussing confidence, competition, and what comes after sports.

The studies draw on Vogel’s 31-day devotional, True Identity: An Athlete’s Guide to Finding Peace in All Circumstances, which includes lessons from Scottie Scheffler, Clayton Kershaw, and Dansby Swanson.

One lesson featuring Swanson explores giving yourself grace after a mistake. Another, featuring former MLB manager Mike Shildt, examines the difference between learning from an error and beating yourself up over it.

For Identity Sports, the next step is getting more athletes to lead those conversations themselves, so the support doesn’t disappear when a meeting ends.

“Understanding our identity in Christ is freedom,” says Vogel. “It allows us to play like a kid again, enjoy the process and give everything we have without letting the scoreboard define us.”

Harvard’s research also found that young people who feel needed and believe they’re making a difference in others’ lives are more likely to experience meaning and purpose.

For Identity Sports, that’s the bigger goal: building lasting relationships where athletes eventually become mentors themselves.

Every athlete eventually plays their last game. Vogel wants athletes to know that leaving the game doesn’t mean losing themselves.

Insider Takeaways

  • More Than a Scoreboard: Identity Sports teaches that athletes can find their worth in Christian faith, not just wins, stats, or playing time.
  • Athletes Helping Athletes: Twelve inaugural Identity Captains are leading studies and mentoring others, with groups across six states and additional virtual programs.
  • A New Kind of Team Meeting: The 12-week Bible studies explore Foundation, Pressure, Adversity, and Purpose, using the True Identity devotional as a resource.
  • From the Field to the Future: Former Duke quarterback Chris Katrenick is among the leaders helping young athletes navigate confidence, competition, and life beyond sports.

Learn more about Identity Sports, its Bible studies, and the True Identity devotional at identitysports.com and identitysports.com/devotionals.